ASPEN
PLUS
- · Aspen Plus Has Solids Handling Capabilities In It.
- · It Has An "Automatic Recycle" Capability Whereas In HYSYS You Have To Add Them Manually.
- · Better User Interface
- · Good For Polymers
- · Aspen Plus Evolved As A Chemical Process Simulator - It Is Very Strong For Simulating Non-Ideal Properties, Systems With Electrolytes, Solids, Azeotropes, And Chemical Reactions. It Is Also Strong For Modeling Large-Scale Flowsheets (Using The Equation-Oriented Approach).
- · Aspen Plus Thermodynamic Library Is Considered To Be Quite Extensive And Hence Considered Quite Useful In Simulation Of Fine Chemicals And Pharmaceutical Chemicals
- · Aspen Plus Is Better Suited For Chemical Process Design Whilst HYSYS Is Best For Hydrocarbon Process Design (Both Upstream And Downstream But Mainly Downstream).
- · Very Absurd And Obsolete Dynamic Module.
PRO II
- · Bad Support
- · Much More Friendly - Easy To Set Up
- · Runs Many More Iteration With Just One Click As Compared To Hyssops
- · We Can Model Solids Inside It
- · We Can Develop An Entire Spreadsheet On The Flowsheet To Perform Sensitivity Analysis And See The Result At Once
- · However We Have To Create A Spreadsheet For It For Specific Label On The Flowsheet
- · We Can Ignore A Specific Section Of Flowsheet And Conserve The Rest And Then Converge The Remaining
- · Suplur Removal Unit Can Set Up A Unit Operator With Specifications At The Outlet
- · Crashes a lot more
HYSYS
- · Hard To Set Up
- · Good Support
- · Hysys Cannot Model Sulfur Recovery Units, Either. However, Hysys May Be Able To Do Some Processes Outside Of Oil & Gas, I Don't Know, Never Tried.
- · Hysys Cannot Model Any Sour Process Or Wet Process Very Well.
PROMAX
- · Amine Sweetening, Dehydration And Sulfur Recovery Makes Promax The Best
No comments:
Post a Comment